Buy silken tofu to blend and firm, extra firm or super firm to cook, then choose between blocks by the protein per serving, not the firmness word. Our pick for cubes that go straight into a pan is Hodo Organic Extra Firm: 14 g of protein per 3 oz serving, and the maker says no pressing.
House Foods sells two tofus called Super Firm, and its pages describe both in the same words: “Our firmest, most dense tofu”. The water-packed one has 9 g of protein in a 3 oz serving. The vacuum-packed one has 14 g. Same maker, same word, same serving size, 5 g apart. The smaller pack even holds more protein, about 42 g in the 8 oz vacuum pack against about 31.5 g in the 10 oz tub, our arithmetic from the servings each page gives. Both pages then say “Drain, press, and marinate”, which is good advice for a tub of water and a puzzling one for a block that was vacuum-sealed.
What firm, extra firm and super firm actually measure
House Foods answers that in its FAQ: firmness depends on how much water is pressed out, more water removed makes firmer tofu, and soft tofu skips the pressing and is made from slightly thicker soy milk instead. Which salt did the setting is a separate question, and our guide to nigari and gypsum reads that part of the label brand by brand. A 2016 processing column in the Institute of Food Technologists’ magazine says the same from the factory side: the curd is pressed to varying degrees, firmer tofu under higher loads, while soft and silken tofu is not pressed at all and sets inside its own package. Mori-Nu describes its silken that way: the hot soy slurry is poured into the box, the box is sealed, and the tofu forms inside, with a water content a little higher than tub tofu.
So the word on the front is the maker’s own scale, and the scales don’t line up. Within one brand, protein per serving climbs with each step: Nasoya goes 4 g for silken, 8 g for firm and 9 g for extra firm, and House Foods’ Premium line goes 5 g for silken and soft, 6 g for medium firm, 7 g for firm and 8 g for extra firm. Across brands it falls apart. House Foods’ extra firm has the same 8 g as Nasoya’s plain firm, and Mori-Nu sells a Silken Extra Firm with 7 g, half of Hodo’s extra firm. Nothing we read for this article sets a shared definition for any of these words.
The protein line is the number that travels, because every block below that shows a panel uses the same 3 oz (85 g) serving.
Nine tofu blocks by protein per serving
Protein is per 3 oz serving as each maker’s page or pictured panel gives it; the per-100 g column is our arithmetic. “Press?” is what the maker’s page says, not our advice.
| Block | Sold as | Protein per 3 oz (85 g) | Per 100 g (our arithmetic) | Press? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nasoya Silken | Silken | 4 g | 4.7 g | No |
| Mori-Nu Silken Extra Firm | Silken, shelf-stable box | 7 g | 8.2 g | Not stated |
| Nasoya Organic Firm | Firm | 8 g | 9.4 g | Yes |
| House Foods Premium Tofu Extra Firm | Extra firm | 8 g | 9.4 g | Yes |
| Nasoya Organic Extra Firm | Extra firm | 9 g | 10.6 g | Yes |
| House Foods Organic Tofu Super Firm | Super firm, 10 oz | 9 g | 10.6 g | Yes |
| House Foods Organic Vacuum-Packed Tofu Super Firm | Super firm, vacuum-packed, 8 oz | 14 g | 16.5 g | Yes |
| Hodo Organic Extra Firm | Extra firm | 14 g | 16.5 g | No |
| 365 by Whole Foods Market Extra Firm Tofu, Vacuum Packed | Extra firm, vacuum-packed, 14 oz | Not on the listing | n/a | Not stated |
None of the nine ingredient lists names an animal ingredient. They run to soybeans and water set with one to three firming agents, plus soy protein isolate in the Mori-Nu box. Mori-Nu and Nasoya mark their blocks vegan, as does the Whole Foods listing; the House Foods and Hodo product pages don’t use the word, and Hodo’s says plant-based.
The nine, one at a time
Nasoya Silken
Nasoya calls it the softest variety, custard-like, and sells it for blending and pureeing into desserts and sauces. Nasoya says to drain it and pat it dry, without pressing. The ingredient list is identical to Nasoya’s firm block: water, organic soybeans and less than 2% of calcium sulfate and magnesium chloride. What differs is what was done to the curd, and it shows on the panel, 4 g of protein per 3 oz, the lowest of the nine. Buy it for a smoothie or a chocolate pudding. Do not buy it to cube.
Mori-Nu Silken Extra Firm
This is the box that lives in the cupboard, since Mori-Nu says it needs no refrigeration until it is opened. The list is water, soybeans, soy protein isolate, glucono-delta-lactone and calcium chloride, labeled vegan, 7 g of protein per 3 oz. Mori-Nu suggests it for grilling and stir frying, and its own FAQ says its silken holds a little more water than tub tofu. “Extra firm” here is extra firm for a silken tofu. If you picture the dense block in the refrigerated case, this is not it. Once open, it goes in an airtight container, not under water, and gets used within 2 days.
Nasoya Organic Firm
Nasoya describes its firm block as slightly softer and more tender than its extra firm, and points it at scrambles, soups, sandwiches and grilling. The panel gives 8 g of protein per 3 oz, about 4.5 servings to the block, and Nasoya recommends pressing it. For a tofu scramble, the slightly softer curd is the point. For crisp cubes, the extra firm below costs you nothing in protein to switch to.
House Foods Premium Tofu Extra Firm
Sold in 12 oz and 16 oz tubs, set with calcium sulfate and calcium chloride, 8 g of protein per 3 oz. House Foods suggests burgers and tacos, pan-fried or air-fried after you drain and press it. By the panel it is level with Nasoya’s firm, so if you switch between the two brands, don’t assume their extra firm means more than the other’s firm.
Nasoya Organic Extra Firm
Water, organic soybeans, calcium sulfate and magnesium chloride, and 9 g of protein in a 3 oz serving. Nasoya’s page calls the brand America’s number one tofu brand for 45 years and says it is in more than 25,000 grocery stores. That is a lot of tubs to drain. Press it first; Nasoya gives three ways, from a heavy object for 15 to 30 minutes to blotting with a paper towel.
House Foods Organic Tofu Super Firm
This is the 10 oz tub, set with calcium sulfate and calcium chloride, with 9 g of protein per 3 oz and about 3.5 servings. Its page calls it “The firmest of all tofu”, though its panel reads the same 9 g as Nasoya\’s extra firm. Buy it if it is the super firm your store carries. If the vacuum pack below is on the next shelf, buy that instead.
House Foods Organic Vacuum-Packed Tofu Super Firm
An 8 oz vacuum pack with 14 g of protein in each 3 oz serving, about 3 servings, set with calcium sulfate and glucono delta lactone. The page’s own tagline calls it “Extra firm, vacuum-sealed tofu” above a product named Super Firm, so even the maker could not pick one word for it. House Foods suggests it for steaks and bacon, grilled or air-fried. Of the two super firms, this is the one to buy; it is the small pack, so plan on one per two people rather than one per family.
Hodo Organic Extra Firm
This is our pick. Water, organic soybeans and calcium sulfate, 14 g of protein per 3 oz, about 3 servings, and 260 mg of calcium a serving. Hodo says to use it straight from the package with no pressing, and suggests it cold in a salad as well as stir-fried. The same page also says “48g of protein per package”; 14 g times about 3 servings comes to about 42 g by our arithmetic, so trust the panel over the headline. The catch is the price. The Columbus Circle Whole Foods Market in New York listed it at $6.99, or $0.70 an ounce, on 15 November 2026. If a tofu bill matters more to you than skipping the press, the 365 vacuum pack below cost about a third as much per ounce on the same store’s listings, by our arithmetic.
365 by Whole Foods Market Extra Firm Tofu, Vacuum Packed
$3.49 for 14 oz, $0.25 an ounce, at the same store on the same day. The listing marks it vegan. Its firming agents are given as “calcium sulfate and/or glucono delta-lactone and/or magnesium chloride”, which is an ingredient list hedging its bets, and the listing shows no nutrition panel. So we cannot put a protein number next to it. Read the panel on the pack in your hand before you count on it matching Hodo.
Which tofu for which dish
For anything blended, a smoothie or a pudding, use silken; Nasoya sells its silken for exactly that, and the shelf-stable Mori-Nu box is the one to keep in the cupboard for it. For scrambles and soups, a firm block like Nasoya’s does the job. For stir-fries and kebabs, take extra firm or super firm and press the water-packed ones, or buy a vacuum pack and skip most of the pressing. For heating a block fast, our guide to microwaving tofu starts from the same no-press blocks. For cold slices in a salad, Hodo’s page suggests eating it straight from the package.
How to pick a block in the aisle
Decide the dish first, because silken against everything else is the one split the firmness words do get right. Then turn the pack over and compare the protein line. On the panels above, the higher the number, the further up its own maker’s firmness scale the block sits, and it is the one figure you can hold against a second brand. Vacuum-packed blocks carry no tub of water, so check whether the pack says to press at all.
For vegan status, a plain block’s list is short enough to read before the case door closes. The risk sits in flavored and specialty tofu, where a sauce or something else gets added, and our guide to whether tofu is plant-based reads those labels, including the one tofu we found with egg in it. If it is cubes for tonight, the Hodo block goes from the pack to the pan without the press.
Sources
- Hodo, Organic Extra Firm Tofu: ingredients, nutrition and no pressing
- House Foods, Organic Tofu Super Firm
- House Foods, Organic Vacuum-Packed Tofu Super Firm
- House Foods, FAQs: what makes tofu soft, firm or extra firm
- McHugh, How tofu is processed, Food Technology (Institute of Food Technologists), February 2016
- Mori-Nu, FAQ: how silken tofu sets in the box, water content and storing opened tofu
- Nasoya, Silken Tofu (ingredients and pictured nutrition panel)
- Nasoya, Organic Firm Tofu (ingredients and pictured nutrition panel)
- Nasoya, Organic Extra Firm Tofu (ingredients, pictured nutrition panel and pressing)
- House Foods, Premium Tofu Silken
- House Foods, Premium Tofu Soft
- House Foods, Premium Tofu Medium Firm
- House Foods, Premium Tofu Firm
- House Foods, Premium Tofu Extra Firm
- Mori-Nu, Silken Tofu Extra Firm: ingredients, vegan label, storage and nutrition
- Whole Foods Market, 365 by Whole Foods Market Extra Firm Tofu, Vacuum Packed, 14 oz (price, ingredients and dietary type, 15 Nov 2026)
- Whole Foods Market, Hodo Extra Firm Organic Tofu (price, 15 Nov 2026)








