Usually more gas at first, and mostly not for long. Beans carry sugars your small intestine can’t digest, so bacteria in the large intestine ferment them into gas. In three feeding studies of ½ cup of beans daily, half or fewer noticed more gas in week 1, and most who did said it faded within 2 to 3 weeks.
Some of the people who reported more gas in those studies weren’t eating beans at the time. Each trial had a control group, fed canned carrots or a soup with no known gas-producing ingredients, and 3% to 11% of them reported more gas anyway. The authors raise the possibility that people who expect beans to give them gas perceive more of it, and point to an older trial of the fat substitute olestra, in which volunteers given a product labeled as containing it reported digestive symptoms although it contained none. None of that makes your gas imaginary. It does make a week of close attention to your own digestion a poor measuring instrument, and you are taking that measurement in exactly the week you started the beans. If one particular food sets you off every time, our piece on whether eggplant causes gas shows how much the serving size changes the answer.
Why does a vegan diet cause more gas?
Because more of what you eat reaches the bacteria. Gas in the large intestine comes from bacteria breaking down the sugars, starches and fiber that the stomach and small intestine don’t fully digest, according to NIDDK, the US institute for digestive diseases. Beans add a particular pair of sugars, raffinose and stachyose, which human digestive enzymes can’t break down alone. Bacteria ferment them instead, and the byproducts are hydrogen, carbon dioxide, methane and sometimes sulfur, depending on the bacteria. Winham and Hutchins, the researchers behind the three bean studies, call more flatulence an expected outcome for some people when fiber intake rises, particularly for people who ate little fiber before. NIDDK, from the other end, says some people have more gas symptoms when they eat too much fiber.
Not every bean hits the same. In the first week of the two cross-over trials, 50% of volunteers on pinto beans and 47% on vegetarian baked beans reported more gas, against 19% on black-eyed peas. The pinto and baked beans carried 7 g of fiber per ½ cup and the black-eyed peas 4 g, yet the authors say fiber alone doesn’t explain the differences they saw. Their advice is to try different bean varieties to see which ones suit you, which is a more useful conclusion than deciding that beans as a class are out to get you.
How long does vegan gas last?
For most people, a couple of weeks. In the pinto bean and black-eyed pea trial, reports of more gas on pinto beans fell from 50% in week 1 to 6% in week 2, and no more than two people a week reported it for the rest of the 8 weeks. Baked beans took longer: 47% in week 1, 24% in week 2, 29% in week 3, then 7% to 11% from week 4 on. Across the studies, 70% or more of the people who noticed extra gas felt it had gone by the second or third week.
The longest trial is the one to read if you are still waiting. Over 12 weeks of daily pinto beans, 45% reported more gas in week 1 and 30% in week 3, and between 15% and 23% kept reporting it from week 6 to week 12. So the gas fades for most people and stays for a minority, and the authors found no consistent predictor, such as sex or age, of who ends up in the minority.
The old companion page on this site promised a wider adjustment phase after going vegan, everything from headaches to breakouts. Nothing we read for this article describes one, and the weekly questionnaire in these trials asked only about the gut.
Is bloating just trapped gas?
Not always. Bloating is a feeling of fullness or swelling in the belly. Summarizing earlier research, Winham and Hutchins note that in some people gas pools in the gut whether or not more of it is being made, and that slow movement of gas through the gut can cause bloating with no increase in gas at all, so different mechanisms produce flatulence and bloating.
Bloating also lingered in their 12-week pinto bean trial: 25% reported more of it in week 1, 40% in week 2, and between 10% and 28% in each week after that. A small trial of the enzyme alpha-galactosidase separates the two more cleanly. Nineteen people ate meatless chili with drops of the enzyme or a placebo, a week apart; on the enzyme they had fewer flatulence events per hour over the next 6 hours, though the gap was significant only in the fifth hour, and there was no difference in bloating or pain. If the swelling bothers you more than the gas, that is worth knowing before you buy anything for it.
Do vegan farts smell worse?
The page this one replaces said so, at length. Taken together, the two studies we found hint the other way. Researchers at the Minneapolis Veterans Affairs Medical Center collected flatus from 16 healthy people who ate pinto beans and lactulose to increase their output, and found that malodor correlated significantly with hydrogen sulfide. They concluded that sulfur gases are the major, though not the only, source of the smell. NIDDK says the same in one line, that the odor may be due to sulfur in the flatus.
So the question is what feeds the sulfur. In a controlled feeding study, 5 healthy men lived in a metabolic suite and ate 5 diets for 10 days each, from a vegetarian diet with no meat up to 600 g of meat a day. Sulfide in their stool rose from 0.22 mmol/kg on the meat-free diet to 3.38 mmol/kg on the highest-meat one, about 15 times as much (our arithmetic), and the authors concluded that protein from meat is an important substrate for sulfide production by bacteria in the large intestine.
Nothing we read supports the claim that a plant diet makes flatus smell worse. The old page blamed broccoli and garlic for the sulfur, and nothing we read measured flatus odor after eating them. The most effective odor fix we found was upholstery: in the Minneapolis study, a charcoal-lined cushion adsorbed more than 90% of the sulfur gases.
What to try first
Start with less. The bean study authors suggest eating smaller portions of beans at first, or splitting a serving in half, and building up from there.
Canned beans, drained and rinsed, carry less of the gas-making sugars. Monash University’s FODMAP team says canned legumes, or legumes boiled and drained, tend to be lower in FODMAPs, because some of the oligosaccharides leach into the canning or cooking water and go with it when you drain and rinse.
If you cook from dried, soak them. In a Washington State University study of lentils, chickpeas, peas and soybeans, soaking reduced the oligosaccharides in all four, and raffinose leached out faster than the others. Cooking after soaking cut them further only in the lentils; in the other three the content stayed the same or even rose. For those three, the soak was the step that counted. Neither of these studies measured gas in people, only what was left in the beans.
Alpha-galactosidase is the over-the-counter option, sold as Beano in the oldest trial. Besides the chili study above, a 2007 trial gave 8 healthy volunteers 420 g of cooked beans with the enzyme or a placebo, and the higher of two doses, 1,200 GalU, significantly reduced both breath hydrogen and the severity of flatulence. Both trials are small, 19 people and 8.
Talk to a doctor if gas symptoms bother you, if they change suddenly, or if they come with abdominal pain, constipation, diarrhea or weight loss, which is NIDDK’s list of reasons to go.
The part we are least sure about is the smell. The best evidence we found comes from two studies that never met: 5 men eating measured amounts of meat for 10 days, and 16 people eating pinto beans and lactulose so researchers could study the odor. Neither describes its volunteers as vegan. If you were planning to settle the whole thing with a probiotic instead, NIDDK says to talk with your doctor before using supplements or probiotics, for safety reasons, and our roundup of vegan probiotic supplements reads what is actually on their labels.
Sources
- Winham and Hutchins (2011), Perceptions of flatulence from bean consumption among adults in 3 feeding studies, Nutrition Journal
- NIDDK: symptoms and causes of gas in the digestive tract
- NIDDK: eating, diet and nutrition for gas in the digestive tract
- Ganiats et al. (1994), Does Beano prevent gas? A double-blind crossover study of oral alpha-galactosidase, Journal of Family Practice
- Suarez, Springfield and Levitt (1998), Identification of gases responsible for the odour of human flatus, Gut
- Magee et al. (2000), Contribution of dietary protein to sulfide production in the large intestine, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition
- Monash FODMAP: including legumes on a low FODMAP diet (canned and drained legumes)
- Han and Baik (2006), Oligosaccharide content of legumes and their reduction by soaking and cooking, Cereal Chemistry
- Di Stefano et al. (2007), The effect of oral alpha-galactosidase on intestinal gas production and gas-related symptoms, Digestive Diseases and Sciences
- NIDDK: treatment for gas in the digestive tract








