Does veganism really help animals? Yes, as odds, and nearly all of them are chickens

Yes. Going vegan helps animals as a probability rather than a fixed body count: a skipped purchase rarely changes an order, and now and then changes a whole crate. Nearly all the land animals at stake are chickens. US plants slaughtered about 320 chickens for every head of cattle in 2025 (our arithmetic from USDA counts).

The old version of this page said one vegan spares about 95 animals a year, then said 105 a few sections later, and cited nothing for either. That is a good year’s growth for a number with no source. Here is one with a source. In 2025 the average young chicken weighed 6.62 lb alive at slaughter in US plants, and the average head of cattle weighed 1,432 lb. So a pound of live chicken is about 216 times as many animals as a pound of live cattle (our arithmetic). Anyone who swaps beef for chicken to eat less red meat multiplies the number of animals behind each pound many times over. The dinner-table line that one person changes nothing deserves a fair hearing too, and gets one below. For the table-manners side of that conversation, there is our guide to handling vegan criticism.

Where the animals actually are

USDA’s National Agricultural Statistics Service publishes yearly slaughter counts for poultry and for livestock. For 2025:

AnimalSlaughtered in 2025Average live weightAnimals per 1,000 lb live weight (our arithmetic)
Young chickens9.58 billion6.62 lb151
Young turkeys189 million31.90 lb31
Hogs128 million289 lb3.5
Cattle29.8 million1,432 lb0.7

Add every species in the two reports together, ducks and sheep included, and chickens, spent hens among them, come to about 96 of every 100 land animals slaughtered (our arithmetic; the poultry counts cover federally inspected plants, the livestock counts commercial plants). Live weight is not meat on the plate, and the share of an animal that ends up as meat differs by species, so read the last column as a rough guide. These reports count animals at slaughter, so fish sit outside every figure here, and laying hens show up only at the end of lay, among the 106 million birds the poultry report calls mature chickens. Field animals killed growing crops sit outside them too; why crop deaths don’t make veganism pointless counts those per person fed.

The case that one person changes nothing

Shelly Kagan, who goes on to argue against it, states the intuition better than most people at a dinner table. The chickens at the supermarket are already dead, and his own purchase seems to make “no difference at all to how many chickens are ordered by the store”.

Mark Budolfson pushed the point much further in 2019, and his version is the one worth answering. Real supply chains, he argues, typically have buffers built in by noise and inefficiency. Ranchers who own their grazing land and have decided to invest in cattle tend to raise as many cattle as they can afford to breed and feed, and many use how well they feed the herd as a cushion when markets turn; ranchers on government grazing permits tend to graze the maximum the permits allow. In the poultry industry, he writes, demand is relatively inelastic and profits depend mostly on the cost of inputs such as feed and fuel. His conclusion is that one person’s chance of making a difference can be small enough that buying is the option with the higher expected value, and that the argument Kagan and others made for equating one person’s expected effect with the average effect of everyone’s choices is unsound. If he is right, the honest number for any one vegan sits below the average, possibly far below it, and a page promising 95 animals a year was selling something.

Why the odds still count

Kagan’s answer to the original intuition, written years before Budolfson’s paper, starts with a butcher who orders chickens in crates of 25. Picture the counter wired with a light that flashes yellow when 24 have sold. Buy a chicken on yellow and you trigger the order for 25 more; buy on green and nothing happens. Real counters have no such light, so every shopper holds a 1 in 25 chance of being the one who triggers the order, and the expected harm of buying works out to one chicken’s worth of suffering. The trigger could be 50 purchases, or 100, or 144, or no precise number at all, Kagan adds; as long as the butcher keeps his orders roughly in line with sales, the expected harm stays at about one chicken.

Peter Singer made the same move in 1980. He offered, as merely an example, one fewer 20,000-bird chicken unit for every 10,000 vegetarians, and admitted in the next sentence that he had no idea what the true figure would be. I like him more for that sentence. It is also where the evidence stops. Kagan’s 25 is invented on purpose, Singer’s 10,000 is an example by his own account, and in the parts of Budolfson’s paper available to us he describes his buffers rather than counting them. Nothing we read for this page measures the actual chance that one shopper changes an order at a real store.

Our line

Our line at Vegan Pots is that veganism helps animals in expectation, and that the honest way to say so is as odds rather than as a tally. Budolfson’s buffers are a good reason to retire the 95-animals figure. They make the odds longer and push the expected effect below the average. They do not make it zero, and somewhere up the chain Kagan’s butcher still has to decide how many crates to order.

Where to start follows from the table. If you are cutting animal products in stages, chicken is where the animals are, and replacing beef with chicken is the change that moves the count the wrong way (our arithmetic, from the figures above).

The part I’m least sure about is the size of those odds. If the chain is as loose as Budolfson describes, one person’s chance of shifting an order could be far below 1 in 25, and nothing we read for this page puts a number on it. For a case where the animal already exists and the question is what you owe her, read why we say eggs from rescued hens still aren’t vegan.

Sources

Share your love
Tara Weaver
Tara Weaver

Tara has been vegan since 2012. She cooks for fun, invents dishes for the site and has tried more vegan beauty products than she can count. She writes about beauty and personal care, fashion and materials, everyday vegan living, the ethics debates and the recipes. No formal training, plenty of practice, and a firm belief that dinner should taste good first.